toolbox – Asia https://blogs.dw.com/asia DW-AKADEMIE’s Asia blog is a forum on media development throughout the region. Mon, 03 Dec 2018 13:59:02 +0000 en-GB hourly 1 Using an “axis of importance” diagram to evaluate sources https://blogs.dw.com/asia/2011/04/12/using-an-axis-of-importance-diagram-to-evaluate-sources/ Tue, 12 Apr 2011 05:35:05 +0000 http://blogs.dw.com/asia/?p=863  
By Daniel Hirschler
When I look at training journalists – or as is the case at the National University of Laos (NUOL) in Vientiane – training journalism teachers, I try to focus on the basics: What makes a journalist a journalist? And what is it that he or she has to contribute to creating “added value” in the information chain?

 

Out of one workshop at NUOL came a good tool that fits perfectly into that quest. It’s a diagram that helps journalists evaluate their sources (see photo at left, click to enlarge).
 
The process is as follows: If you have a source, first decide whether he or she is to be categorized as less or more important (more about this ranking later).
 
 
Then take a look at what the person is saying: is it more of a rumor or opinion or is it instead a fact (or observation). Place the source accordingly along those two axes (see photo at right).
 
Using an “axis of importance” diagram led in this case to fruitful discussions about this crucial question. For me this is one of the main values of working with such “open” visual tools. They facilitate the structuring of the learning process and at the same time support rather than hinder the "flow" of a group.
 
The group we were working with came up with the following “indicators” of importance (in orange at the bottom of photo at left).
 
The tool was developed jointly by my colleagues Michael Karhausen and Linda Rath-Wiggins. Michael is a journalist, Linda’s main job is developing new formats for Deutsche Welle’s multimedia content. Both work as consultants and trainers with DW-AKADEMIE and each brought different mindsets to the situation.
 
As a seasoned reporter and editor involved mainly in day-to-day newsgathering, Michael isn't likely to use such a diagram on paper in his daily routine. One could say he has it stored it in the back of his mind; it comprises gut feeling, instinct and experience. Linda is currently investigating data journalism where the main idea is to visualize complex data sets so that audiences can make sense of them.
 
Out of this combination came a tool that is very helpful for training and teaching. It serves as a focal point for discussions, facilitates communication and makes it easy for learners to gain entry into the somewhat complex field of evaluating sources for stories.
 
Do you have suggestions regarding this tool? Or want to share one of yours with us? Leave a comment below.
 
Daniel Hirschler is a DW-AKADEMIE trainer and project manager who worked extensively in Laos.
Photo credits: Daniel Hirschler and Michael Karhausen
]]>
Educators embark into a new era of journalism in Laos https://blogs.dw.com/asia/2011/04/05/educators-embark-into-a-new-era-of-journalism-in-laos/ https://blogs.dw.com/asia/2011/04/05/educators-embark-into-a-new-era-of-journalism-in-laos/#comments Tue, 05 Apr 2011 07:44:58 +0000 http://blogs.dw.com/asia/?p=857  

Is there a proper definition of journalism in the Lao language? Since DW-AKADEMIE’s first workshop on journalism at the National University of Laos in Vientiane, there is. It was conceived by 15 staff teachers of the Department of Mass Communication at the Faculty of Letters – after long discussions revolving around somewhat abstract terms like “media”, “the public”, “society” and “information”. 

Lao is not a language that lends itself to describing abstract ideas. Yet the 15 teachers feel it was worth the effort to lay a foundation they now can build upon. They are learning the mindset, tools and skills that in combination make a journalist. The reasoning behind this is that they are the ones training a new generation of Lao students who are eager to take on the profession.

 

Redefining public and professional understanding of journalism

Laos is opening up its state-controlled media market. The new economic era, started in the late 1980’s, only recently reached the media.

Today, more and more print publications and privately funded but state-controlled television and radio channels are starting up.

In this era of transition there is a dire need for new concepts. This involves exploring the very definition of journalism and the role of journalists.

Previously, a journalist served the government, “explaining the party’s policy to the people”. This is a concept that a growing number of people reject by simply switching off. The ruling People’s Revolutionary Party now officially wants to swap this premise for one that includes two-way communication between politicians and the people.

 

Uniting practice and theory

Still, the old mental models are deeply rooted – and so discussions about changing them are lively.

The idea is for the university to become the focal point for dialogue about the concept of journalism in the making of a new Laos.

Until then, practical training is interwoven with more theoretical exploration. “Types of questions and how to use them” was the main focus of a workshop in March. 

The trainees are trainers themselves, so DW-AKADEMIE trainers put emphasis on creating a learning situation that conveys not only knowledge but also methods.

 

Here’s one training method that was both fun and effective. It’s called “Human Bingo” and is quite helpful for training the mechanics of open and closed questions:

 

Each participant tells the trainer something special about himself that the other participants don’t know or expect. It can be a talent, dream, wishes, plans. The trainer collects the statements individually (and hidden from the rest of the group), writes them down on individual cards that are then redistributed. Each participant gets one card and has to find out which statements belong to whom. Their first questions have to be general and open questions. If the interviewer thinks that the statement he’s holding in his hands fits the interviewee, he can ask directly about his assumption. But he should choose carefully when to guess because this is only allowed twice per person.

 

Try it yourself – it also works well as a warm up for all kind of group activities.

 

Contributed and photographed by Daniel Hirschler and Michael Karhausen

]]>
https://blogs.dw.com/asia/2011/04/05/educators-embark-into-a-new-era-of-journalism-in-laos/feed/ 1